Smedley Doesn't Like Microtransactions, "Hated Defending" Them
Now that he's not bound by a PR department and can say what he wants, former SOE/Daybreak and current Pixelmage Games CEO John Smedley can tell everyone what he really thinks about free-to-play and microtransactions. And he was so shy and reserved before!
Speaking in a Reddit AMA earlier this week to promote his company's new game Hero's Song, Smedley had some harsh words to say about microtransactions:
I don't like Microtransactions because I worked on too many games with them. They change the feeling of development to one where you feel like you have to worry about the business instead of the gameplay. That leads to tons of compromises. I hated that. I also hated defending stuff we did to make money to our players.. because they're right.. they know we spent too much time focusing on that stuff.
That's pretty damning, coming from the man who ran a company that jumped whole-heartedly into the free-to-play/microtransaction pool. He's not wrong, of course; it doesn't take insider information to realize that some microtransactions just don't feel right, that they're clearly meant to be for the benefit of the company, not the player, and talk like how they "give you freedom to play how you want" is pure spin.
Not every microtransaction or game with microtransactions is bad, though, and we could all come up with some good examples. I wonder, though, if SOE/Daybreak, as big a company as it was, had to "go too far" with some of its decisions to justify its larger budgets for its games. Smaller, more focused, games, like Warframe or Path of Exile, can probably do a better job with their microtransactions than huge, sprawling AAA Free MMOs that have to recoup their plus-sized development costs.
In any case, Smedley promises that "there will be zero selling of any microtransactions in any Pixelmage Games game including Hero's Song," so it's not something he'll have to worry about at his current post. Of course, he used to say he loved free-to-play and microtransactions, too.
Related Articles
About the Author
Jason Winter is a veteran gaming journalist, he brings a wide range of experience to MMOBomb, including two years with Beckett Media where he served as the editor of the leading gaming magazine Massive Online Gamer. He has also written professionally for several gaming websites.
More Stories by Jason WinterRead Next
If you’ve been wanting a taste of Black Desert Online’s character creator, but haven't had the chance to actually try the game out, now’s your chance.
You May Enjoy
The event is underway on Xbox and PlayStation.
More decorating, because that may be all you have left to do at this point.
Feature
I'm All For A Dauntless Update, But I Seriously Dread Where The Game's Monetization Is Headed
Loot boxes, buying weapons, and other "new" features have me questioning the game's blockchain-company-owned future.
This happens just a day after the reveal of the MMO's first raid in 5 years.
Well of course he's going to say that when he's president of Sony games. If he said anything different the board would have had his head.
The graphics of this game aren't great but the game itself looks kind of interesting. I guess I'll have to keep a look out for it and see what its like when it comes out.